Magazine content за Ноябрь 2013 г.
Magazine Cover
Press to zoom

Buy a PDF

ARCHIVE FOR 2013    RUSSIAN

mag->month > 0 ) { ?>

mag->getMonthString();?> mag->year;?>

mag->pdf_file): ?> sess && $this->sess->isArticlePayed()):?>

Ноябрь 2013

CONTENT

 

 

Chief editor’s column

 

Interview of the issue

Pligin V.N. Arbitration courts continue to operate
Chairman of State Duma Committee on Constitutional Legislation and State Construction Vladimir Nikolayevich PLIGIN is answering the questions of Editor-in-Chief of magazine “Zakon” Yan Piskunov
Buy a PDF

 

The Event. Comments of the Experts

Freedom of contract and disposition limits in civil law
One of the instruments most lively discussed by lawyers in November was draft resolution of the plenary session of RF Supreme Arbitration Court “On Freedom of Contract and Its Limits”. We asked the expert to assess positive and negative trends of the resolution, as well as the role it can play for the future judicial practice.

 

Topic of the issue

Davidyan G.М., Jenty F., Nugered D., McDonald Т. Understanding legal ethics should be instilled in students at the genetic level
Editorial Director of magazine “ZAKON” Vladimir Rumak interviewed the participants of the Third scientific and practical student seminar on lawyer’s professional ethics, which took place at the law department of Lomonosov Moscow State University on November 5–9, 2013.
Buy a PDF

 

Davidyan G.М. Some problems of lawyer’s professional ethics in the Russian Federation
The article covers the basic problems hindering development of lawyer’s professional ethics as a fundamental basis of the legal profession in the Russian Federation. It analyzes the problems connected with the lack of uniform standards for various categories of lawyers, uncertainty of the legal effect of special instruments governing legal ethics, teaching professional ethics as an academic discipline at legal universities. The author suggests introducing a single qualifying exam for all graduates of legal universities, as well as improvement of standards for teaching lawyer’s ethics in the curricula of specialized universities.
Keywords: lawyer’s professional ethics, code of ethics, ethic standards, legal profession
Buy a PDF

 

Shugurov M.V. Some issues of the ethics of judges in the European Court of Human Rights
The article analyzes the legal views of the European Court of Human Rights concerning the ethic aspect of the human right to a fair trial. The author dwells upon these views taking into account the COE’s approach to justice in democratic society. Much attention is paid to moral and ethical codes of conduct and activity of ECtHR judges, for which purpose the Resolution on Ethics of 2010 is analyzed. The author focuses on the study of ECtHR views on independence and neutrality, being not only institutional but ethic criteria of fair justice.
Keywords: European Court of Human Rights, judicial ethics, independence, neutrality, international justice
Buy a PDF

 

Vlasov D.I. Courtesy in international arbitration, or the new “IBA Guidelines on Party Representation in International Arbitration”
Due to the increased role of international arbitration as a means of resolving disputes involving the foreign element and its further internationalization, the cases when the interests of parties are represented by lawyers of different legal orders following different codes of professional conduct and ethics are becoming widespread. In this connection it’s interesting to analyze the recently adopted “IBA Guidelines on Party Representation in International Arbitration”, as well as to assess to what extent they differ from the procedure of settling such problems in the Russian law of arbitral procedure.
Keywords: international arbitration, code of professional conduct, ethic norms, representative, code of conduct, arbitration proceedings
Buy a PDF

 

Mekhanoshina I.А. Ethic standards of notarial activity
The article focuses on professional and ethical principles, notarial activity is based on. The author touches upon the history of adoption and potential amendment of Professional Code of Notaries, dwelling on the reasons for today’s claims to notariate on the part of society.
Keywords: notariate, notary, notarial activity, professional ethics, ethic standards, Professional Code of Notaries
Buy a PDF

 

Discussion Board

Belov V.А. When law speaks…
The author explains and develops his views expressed as an expert comment on the topic “Immoral transactions in Russian law” in issue No. 7 of magazine “Zakon” of the current year. Their general meaning is as follows: when law speaks, the rules of morality and other social regulators either support it or subside and don’t interfere. Guided by these considerations, and taking them as a starting point, the author analyzes certain problems of maintaining and application of institutes envisaged by art. 10 and 169 of the EF Civil Code.
Keywords: law, morals, principles of public order and morality, abuse of right, invalidity of legal transaction
Buy a PDF

 

Theory and practice

Novoselova L.А., Mikhailov S.V. On the legal status of documents governing the registration of domain names and disputes connected therewith
The authors touch upon the problem of using two highly efficient alternative ways of domain name dispute settlement, which have nothing in common with either arbitration proceedings, or mediation — Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy and Dispute Resolution Service. The article analyzes the unique legal nature, as well as some procedural features of the above mechanisms.
Keywords: domain names, domain name disputes, intellectual property, UDRP, alternative ways of dispute resolution
Buy a PDF

 

Pepelyaev S.G. On the legal nature of the institute of legal costs
The article continues scientific discussion of attribution of costs to the category of loss that is directly related to the completeness of the reimbursement to the prevailing party. The author argues against a researcher, defending the opposite view, by proving that procedural costs preserve their legal nature of damages despite a special form of reimbursement.
Keywords: legal costs, procedural costs, damages, justice availability
Buy a PDF

 

Alexeev V.А. Issues of liability for unauthorized construction
The article focuses on the basis of civil liability for unauthorized construction. Special attention is paid to two issues: whether no-fault liability for unauthorized construction is possible, and what the legal status of innocent purchasers of such property is.
Keywords: buildings erected without proper legal authorization, developer, real estate, civil liability, unauthorized construction
Buy a PDF

 

Manyak N.I. Checking the judicial act in the court of second instance - guarantee of the right to judicial protection and its integral part
The article investigates the legality of introducing various barriers to appeal a judicial act in an appeals instance in view of internationally recognized requirements and principles of judicial remedy. The author comes to the point that any barriers or exclusion of appeal as the most available and efficient way of remedying miscarriages of justice is inadmissible.
Keywords: judicial remedy, appeals instance, review of judicial decisions, right of appeal, access to justice
Buy a PDF

 

Foreign experience

Geoffroy К. The new EU Regulation on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters is a step towards the final cancellation of exequatur in Europe
The article analyzes the recent changes in the European Union legislation connected with the reform of the Brussels-I Regulation, providing for a new, simplified approach to the recognition and enforcement of judgments. The author interprets the innovative approach of the European legislator as positive experience, which may be perceived by other countries, including Russia.
Keywords: European Union, Brussels-I Regulation, exequatur, jurisdiction, recognition of foreign judgments, enforcement of foreign judgments
Buy a PDF

 

Razgildeev А.V. Administrative Justice: European and US experience and its potential application in Russia
The article analyzes the experience of establishing special courts and other bodies to settle administrative disputes in a number of jurisdictions: in Germany, France, the Netherlands, Great Britain, and the USA. The findings may be useful for administrative justice reform in Russia.
Keywords: administrative justice, administrative courts, specialized courts, pre-trial settlement of disputes

 

Zhidi А. Code of class proceedings: a model for civil law countries.
The article is a translated research of the well-known American processualist Antonio Zhidi, who generalized the international experience of class action application to create a model code of class proceedings for civil law countries.
Keywords: model code, class proceedings, class actions, class action suits.
Buy a PDF